First, the piece is incorrect that e-bike fires are a leading cause of death in New York. There were exactly 17 deaths attributable to lithium-ion battery fires in 2023. Just what those lithium-ion batteries powered is a point we will return to in a moment.
In a city of 8.468 million residents, those 17 deaths – while significant and tragic – are dwarfed by the 380 murders committed in the city in 2023. But within the state of New York, murder doesn’t even make the list of the top 10 causes of death in the state. The top three causes are heart disease, cancer and Covid-19.
It’s fair to observe that New York City is ground zero for lithium-ion battery fires, but as threats go, New Yorkers are five times more likely to die as subway riders than they are in an e-bike fire.
Now, to return to the causes of those lithium-ion battery fires. It seems any time an e-mobility device suffers a lithium-ion battery fire—particularly if that device has two wheels, whether or not it has pedals—it gets labeled an e-bike fire. As we showed in our in-depth reporting on lithium-ion battery fires last fall, not a single death in New York City in 2023 could be attributed to an e-bike. They were all caused by e-scooters, e-mopeds and the like. None of the fires began with an actual e-bike.
That we actually need to define an e-bike has having two wheels, pedals, a handlebar and seat — and everything that doesn’t have pedals isn’t an e-bike — is one of those forehead-slapping events. The sort of inaccurate reporting on the part of Men’s Journal is the cause of some of the confusion in the market about just what devices are dangerous.
We’re dedicated to reporting on quality products made by manufacturers that produce cost-effective e-bikes made to high standards. Indeed, most of the manufacturers we review have either already secured UL certification for their e-bike systems or batteries, or they are in the process of securing that certification.
By misrepresenting the facts, inaccurate reporting can harm such undeserving brands despite their best (and indeed, appropriate and responsible) efforts to manufacture safe products.
*Please help support our efforts at Electric Bike Report. We work hard to provide the highest quality content, news, and reviews for our readers – and our sponsors make all of this possible. Please visit our sponsors from their ads on our website and let them know that you appreciate what they do for the e-bike industry and Electric Bike Report